Dispatch from COP31: My First Day in the Blue Zone by Lana Alnajm

November 11, 2026
My time at COP31 in Antalya has been an incredibly rewarding experience, both academically and personally. Being here has allowed me to move beyond the literature and engage directly with the lawyers, negotiators, researchers, Indigenous representatives, and civil society organizations working on the issues I've been studying. I've been especially struck by the range of perspectives and approaches to climate justice, and by the accountability that communities and civil society actors are demanding from governments, international institutions, and major polluters.
Research focus:
My research is centered on the following questions:
"How do climate-vulnerable states and civil society actors mobilize international legal principles to advance claims for climate finance and loss and damage at COP31?"

"How have alternative international legal pathways, particularly the International Court of Justice's (ICJ's) climate advisory opinion, challenged the limitations of United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) negotiations in advancing accountability for climate change?"
Throughout the conference, I've been examining the relationship between international legal recognition and its translation into political and material outcomes. In particular, I'm interested in whether the ICJ's 2025 Advisory Opinion is creating meaningful leverage for climate-vulnerable states and civil society, and how these legal developments interact with the institutional and political limitations of the UNFCCC.
Conversations and interviews
One of the most valuable conversations I've had was with Sangeetha Iengar, an international human rights barrister, immigration and asylum judge, Research Associate at the University of Oxford, Senior Research Scholar at Yale University, and Director of Oxford's newly established Institute for Law and Policy on Climate Mobility. She has spent over two decades working across asylum, immigration, public law, and international human rights, and now focuses on developing rights-based legal and policy responses to climate mobility.
Our conversation brought together two areas I've been particularly interested in, asylum and migration law, and climate change. I found the intersection between them fascinating. We discussed how climate mobility is often treated as a future humanitarian or migration crisis, when it should instead be understood as a predictable governance and human rights challenge that all states have a responsibility to address.
One of the most interesting ideas she introduced was the concept of habitability: rather than viewing climate mobility exclusively through the question of where people move when they can no longer remain somewhere, we should also ask what governments must do to sustain safe and dignified lives in people's communities for as long as possible. This challenged some of my initial assumptions about the role of the ICJ opinion and how its legal principles might translate into practical protections. She emphasized that international legal recognition alone is not enough when governments lack domestic mandates, institutional ownership, and resources to act. It is also not only a climate vulnerable state issue, all states should be rallying around this and building climate resilient structures that will ensure rights based and sustainable approaches when climate problems arise.
We also discussed the relationship between litigation, diplomacy, and civil society mobilization. Her perspective was that these are not competing approaches. Litigation can establish or clarify obligations, diplomatic processes can build political consensus, and civil society can create the pressure necessary to make governments engage with those obligations. I found this especially relevant to my research, as the success of international legal developments cannot be measured solely by whether particular language survives in a final COP decision, which is what I wanted to understand, but also by whether it changes the terms of political discussion and creates new avenues for accountability which I believe it is currently!
I also had the opportunity to speak with a UAE climate youth negotiator. I was particularly interested in understanding the UAE's position as an OPEC member, its growing investment in renewable energy, particularly solar and wind, and its support for the ICJ advisory opinion during the recent UNGA votes I asked about how the UAE's energy transition and evolving climate diplomacy inform its engagement with international legal developments, especially in comparison with other Arab countries reliant on fossil fuels. It was interesting to hear how she understood the UAE's position and its approach to climate negotiations. She even told me she hoped I would become a negotiator someday, which was a cute moment!

I also spoke with representatives of the Iraqi group at COP. It was especially meaningful to connect with an Iraqi delegation and hear more about their work. I hope to follow up with them and develop more specific questions about Iraq's climate priorities and participation in the negotiations.
Observations from the conference:
I attended several discussions that expanded my understanding of the different ways climate justice is being pursued.
At an Oxfam press conference, representatives emphasized that COP's success should ultimately be judged by whether climate finance reaches the poorest and most vulnerable countries, whether major polluters are held accountable (make polluters pay), and whether new and accessible sources of finance are secured. They also raised concerns about the lack of new finance commitments from wealthier countries and the disconnect between what is happening in negotiation rooms and the realities communities are experiencing.
I also attended discussions on the rights of nature, where speakers explored how legal frameworks can recognize and protect ecosystems, including through legal traditions that predate contemporary environmental law. One particularly interesting contribution examined the Islamic legal concepts of hima, harim, and waqf as frameworks for collective environmental protection and stewardship. I loved seeing other knowledge systems centered in these discussions!
Another event I happened to come across focused on Indigenous perspectives on artificial intelligence and technology-based climate solutions. Speakers challenged the assumption that technological development is inherently beneficial or just, highlighting how data centers, mineral extraction, data extraction, and other infrastructure projects can reproduce patterns of colonialism and dispossession when imposed on Indigenous territories without community consent. They emphasized that Indigenous knowledge should not simply be extracted and repurposed by corporations, but that communities must have authority over the technologies and projects affecting their lands. This raised extremely critical questions about what a just transition actually means, especially given the COP presidency’s AI pledge that the indigenous climate change forum vehemently opposed.
Following the draft negotiations:
One particularly significant development has been the inclusion of language referencing the ICJ Advisory Opinion in the recent draft COP31 cover decision. This is especially interesting given the resistance that international legal obligations have faced in previous negotiations.
During discussions about the draft, I observed disagreements over the role of the cover decision itself and whether it should be used to introduce broader political or institutional mandates. The proposed reference to the ICJ opinion is also contested, with some countries opposing its inclusion. I am particularly interested in following whether this language survives, if it’s gets compromised how it is negotiated, and whether it really shifts the tides in subsequent drafts.
Looking ahead:
Over the next few days, I hope to continue following the formal negotiations, particularly the evolving cover decision and the debates surrounding the ICJ Advisory Opinion. I am also hoping to speak with more Indigenous representatives, Pacific Island organizations and negotiators, and civil society actors.
More broadly, COP31 has made me think about the legitimacy and limitations of the UNFCCC itself. Is the convention still capable of addressing the demands being raised by communities and civil society? How does it reckon with the growing role of international courts, regional legal mechanisms, and grassroots movements in climate governance? And is there true accountability and community participation when delegates and negotiators may be out of touch?
A personal reflection:

Beyond the research, the experience of being at COP has been extraordinary. Entering the Blue Zone for the first time was almost overwhelming. The scale of the conference was incredible, and I loved exploring the different country pavilions. I received a flower from the Moana Pavilion, while the Omani Pavilion generously gave me a collection of gifts and enthusiastically encouraged me to visit and eventually live in Oman!
I also got to do karaoke with two other members of our program. We sang Lush Life, which and I ended the evening by declaring that it would only remain a lush life if we avoided going beyond the 1.5°C threshold and causing a scorched life. It was a fun, much-needed way to end an otherwise very full day.
What has stayed with me most is witnessing the multiplicity of people, perspectives, and forms of work taking place here. There are profound disagreements about what climate justice requires, but there are also so many people doing meaningful work to make institutions answer for their decisions and TAKE ACCOUNTABILITY! Apply pressure! I'm leaving these conversations with more questions than I arrived with, which I think is a good thing. Most importantly, my time here has strengthened my interest in pursuing work at the intersection of international law, human rights, migration, and climate justice! I didn’t really realize that this intersection was so relevant until now! I’m excited to see where the rest of the conference takes me.
About Lana Alnajm: Lana is a Pre-Law Social Policy and Data Science major at Northwestern University. She is attending the COP as part of her Northwestern coursework. She and her team were the first winners of Accelerate Climate Solutions' Building Leadership Around Sustainable Transformation (BLAST) Competition in 2024 with their Seeds of Hope project. She joined our summer internship program that same year and co-authored our Bikeability report. She has remained connected to Accelerate throughout the years, including speaking at the 2025 Chicago Youth Climate Justice Summit and joining the Make Polluters Pay coalition.
About COP31: COP31 is the 31st international climate conference, taking place in Antalya, Turkey. Nation states, excluding the United States this year due to the current administration's anti-science stance on climate change, negotiate to come to concensus on addressing the climate crisis. Many people may be familiar with the "Paris Agreement," which set the goal of holding warming to 1.5°C - this happened at the COP in 2015. COP stands for Conference of the Parties.



Comments